Da`if ahadith of an-Nawawi's Riyadus Salihin
Creator: Shaykh Muhammad Nasir-ud-Deen al-Albani
Date: 2007-06-20
Format: text
Identifier: http://www.islamworld.net/docs/HADITH/RIYADUS.html
Language: en
Subject: hadith
Title: Da`if ahadith of an-Nawawi's Riyadus Salihin
Created on: Mon Mar 17 13:09:03 -0400 2008
Updated on: Wed Jun 20 23:40:40 -0400 2007
Version: 1
Abstract: ... iz, pp. 13- 14 and ad-Da`ifah, no. 3232. 159:944, pg. 487/ 158:948, pg. 177 25)"Imam Shafi'e said it is better to recite the Qur'an near the grave ..." ù Its being his saying is doubtful, rather a repudiation of this view is authentically reported from him ... and Ibn Taimiyah signifies this is in al-Iqtida ... that this is not Imam Shafi'e's saying. Rather it is a innovation. 161:947, pg. 488/ - 26)"Ibn `Umar ... met with nightfall ..." (Abu Daud) ù Its isnad contains unknown narrator/s even though ad-Dhahabi and al-Hakim say it is sahih and Ibn Hajr says its hasan. See ad- Da`ifah, no. 4837. 174:983, pg. 506/ 173:987, pg. 184 27)"Ibn 'Abbas ..." (Tirmidzi) ù I have spoken about it in Mishkat no. 2135 ... da`if. 180:1000, pg. 512/ 179:1004, pg. 186 28)"Abu Darda' ... one who memorizes the first ten verses of Surat al- Kahf ... and in a narration: from the end of Surah-ul Kahf." (Muslim) ù This particular narration 'from the end' instead of 'from the beginning' is shadh (reliable reporter contradicting more reliable reporters). 183:1021, pg. 521/ 182:1025, pg. 189 29)"Abu Sa'id Khudri ..." (Tirmidzi) ù Its isnad is da`if as I have explained in Mishkat, no. 723, although its meaning is correct. 189:1060, pg. 535/ 188:1064, pg. 193 30)"Aisha ... Allah and his angels send down blessings on the right wing of the rows." (Abu Daud, citing on the terms of Muslim) ù Al-Albani brings a long note ... the wording 'upon those on the right of the rows' is shadh or munkar, the correct narration being 'upon those who join up the rows.' See Mishkat, no. 1096, Da`if Abi Daud, no. 153 ... 194:1094, pg. 548/ 193:1098, pg. 197 31)"Abu Hurairah ... Let the Imam stand in the middle and close the gaps ..." (Abu Daud) ù There are unknown reporters in the isnad. See Da`if Abi Daud, no. 105. 194:1096, pg. 548/ 193:1100, pg. 197 32)"Ali ibn Abi Talib ... two rakaats before 'Asr ..." (Abu Daud) ù But the wording 'two rakaats' is shadh and the correct version is 'four rakaats', see Da`if Abi Daud, 235. 200:1121, pg. 558/ 199:1125, pg. 200 33)"Abi Burdah ibn Abi Musa al-Ash'ari ... 'Abdullah ibn `Umar ... takes place from the moment the Imam ascends the pulpit and lasts till the prayer ends." (Muslim) ù The imams have verified its being mauqof to Abu Musa al-Ash'ari, among them al-Daraqutni as I have explained in Da`if Abi Daud, no. 193. 210:1157, pg. 570/ 209:1162, pg. 204 34)"Sa'd ibn Abi Waqqas ... we ... started from Mecca to Madina ..." (Abu Daud) ù Its isnad is da`if ... al-Irwa, no. 467 and ad-Da`ifah, no. 3229. 211:1159, pg. 571/ 210:1164, pg. 204 35)"Abu Hurairah ... when anyone of you who gets up for the night prayer, he should start the same with two brief rakaats." (Muslim) ù And this hadith is related marfu'an from Abu Hurairah by others - from his (S) action - which is correct - as for its being his (S) that is shadh as explained in Da`if Abi Daud, no. 240. 212:1179, pg. 577/ 211:1184, pg. 206 36)"Abu Hurairah ..." (Tirmidzi called it sound) ù Its isnad contains Qurah ibn 'Abdur-Rahman, and he is da`if because of his poor memory, and I have laid out the 'ulamas' criticism of him in the second hadith of Irwa ul Ghalil ... 222:1235, pg. 601/ 221:1240, pg. 215 37)"Mujibat-ul-Bahiliyah ..." (Abu Daud) ù Its isnad is da`if as I have explained in at-Ta'liq ur-Raghib 'alat-Targhib wat-Tarhib, 2/82. 225:1248, pg. 606/ 224:1253, pg. 216 38)"Umm `Umarah al-Ansariyah ..." (Tirmidzi and said it was good) ù And in some versions of Tirmidzi occurs 'hasan sahih', and there is reason to doubt both of these - ad-Da`if, no. 1332. 231:1266, pg. 612/ 230:1271, pg. 218 39)"Uqbah ibn Amir Juhani ... Allah will admit three persons into paradise on account of one arrow ..." (Abu Daud) ù There is weakness in its isnad ... Takhrij Fiqhus-Sirah, pg. 225. 234:1335, pg. 639/ 233:1340, pg. 227 40)"Abu Umamah ... " (Abu Daud) ù Its isnad contains al-Walid ibn Muslim, a mudallis and he has used 'an'anah (from) here. See at-Ta'liq-ur-Raghib, 2/200. 234:1348, pg. 643/ 233:1353, pg. 228 41)"Anas ... A person who goes (out of his house) in search of knowledge, he is on Allah's way and he remains so till he returns." (Tirmidzi said it was good) ù Da`if, Takhrij-ul-Mishkat, no. 220, ad-Da`ifah, no. 2037. 241:1385, pg. 657/ 240:1390, pg. 233 42)"Abu Sa'id al-Khudri ..." (Tirmidzi) ù It is da`if. Mishkat, no. 222. 241:1386, pg. 658/ 240:1391,pg. 233 43)"Abu Hurairah ... Every magnificant and important project not begun with the praise of Allah ..." (Abu Daud) ù The hadith is da`if ... [Full Article...]
